Comparative Analysis of Financial Performance Between Islamic and Conventional Banks: A Study of Efficiency, Profitability, and Risk Resilience
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54471/idarotuna.v7i1.187Keywords:
Financial Performance, Islamic Banking, Conventional Banking, Profitability, Efficiency, Risk ResilienceAbstract
The global banking industry is currently dominated by a dual banking system, creating competition between conventional interest-based models and Islamic profit-and-loss sharing models. Although Islamic banks continue to grow by emphasizing ethical values and transparency, a research gap remains regarding long-term performance resilience, cost of capital structures, and operational efficiency (BOPO) compared to conventional banks, which are more established in terms of economies of scale and digital infrastructure. This study aims to map the performance divergence between these two banking systems to provide guidance for regulators and investors. This research employs a qualitative-descriptive design reinforced by a comparative quantitative approach. The units of analysis focus on Islamic Commercial Banks (BUS) and Conventional Commercial Banks (BUK) in Indonesia during the post-pandemic to recovery era (2020–2025). Secondary data were obtained through annual financial report documentation using a purposive sampling technique. The research instrument utilizes a modified CAMEL ratio framework, including Return on Assets (ROA), Non-Performing Loans/Financing (NPL/NPF), and the Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR). Data analysis was conducted using the Independent Sample T-Test following Kolmogorov-Smirnov normality testing. The findings indicate that Conventional Banks consistently record higher profitability (ROA) due to economies of scale and the flexibility of interest-based instruments. While Conventional Banks are more operationally efficient (BOPO) due to established technological ecosystems, Islamic Banks maintain a higher Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) as a risk buffer. The acceleration of digitalization emerges as a key factor in narrowing the efficiency gap between these two banking systems
Downloads
References
Adha, S. I., & Ar-raniry, U. I. N. (2020). Konversi Bank Konvensional Menjadi Bank Syariah Pada praktiknya struktur tata kelola perusahaan pada perbankan syariah pascakonversi tidak memberikan kewenangan pengawasan kepada IAH ( Investment Account Holders ) terhadap pengelolaan dana mereka oleh ter. Journal of Sharia Economics |, 1.
Al-harbi, A. (2026). The determinants of conventional banks pro fi tability in developing and underdeveloped OIC countries. 24(47), 4–28. https://doi.org/10.1108/JEFAS-05-2018-0043
Alhamrani, E., Bafadhal, H., Islam, U., Sulthan, N., & Saifuddin, T. (2025). LintekEdu : Jurnal Literasi dan Teknologi Pendidikan LintekEdu : Jurnal Literasi dan Teknologi Pendidikan. 6(4), 196–212.
Ananta, G. T., Wiranatakusuma, D. B., Aru, Y., Yudiyanto, A., Aini, N., & Dewi, P. (2024). Kajian Stabilitas Keuangan Bank Syariah : Pendekatan Literature Review. 1–12.
Ank, D. A. N. B., & Eriode, K. O. P. (2020). (dea): p. 15(2).
Apriani Simatupang, E. A. B. N. (2024). Studi Komparatif Tingkat Kesehatan Bank Syariah Dan Bank Konvensional Dengan Pengukuran Rasio Rentabilitas Apriani. 7.
Aprilia, T., Sari, R. M., Adawiyah, R., Efrilia, D., Anggesta, L., & Lulu, T. (2024). Peran Ekonomi Islam Dalam Pembangunan Ekonomi Nasional Yang Berkelanjutan di Era Society 5 . 0. 2(2), 227–237.
Ari, M., & Setiawati, P. C. (2024). Persepsi Nasabah Terhadap Kualitas Pelayanan di Bank Syariah Indonesia. 2, 34–47.
Atasyadila, H. (2024). Pengaruh Digital Banking Terhadap Profitabilitas Dan. Journal of Accounting, Management, and Islamic Economics, Vol.02, No, 469–478.
Awadzie, D. M. (2021). The impact of financial intermediation on bank. 5(05), 96–110.
Baihaqi. (2023). Peran Hukum Syariah dalam Memitigasi Risiko Pembiayaan Mikro. 1.
Banjarnahor, H. (2022). Dampak Camel Terhadap Profitabilitas Perbankan. 16(2), 121–129.
Biasmara, H. A., & Iradianty, A. (2021). Pengaruh Kondisi Makroekonomi Terhadap Risk Profile Pada Bank Umum Syariah di Indonesia. 19(1), 48–56.
Fadoua, J. (2025). Financial Stability in Dual Banking Systems : A Theoretical Comparison between Conventional and Islamic Banks. 5(1), 100–117.
Farah, A. A., Mohamed, M. A., Ali, M., Yusuf, I. A., & Abdulle, M. S. (2025). Impact of Islamic banking on economic growth : a systematic review of SCOPUS-indexed studies ( 2009 – 2024 ) Impact of Islamic banking on economic growth : a systematic review. Cogent Economics & Finance, 13(1). https://doi.org/10.1080/23322039.2025.2490819
Febriani, E. (2025). Arah Strategi Manajemen Keuangan Syariah Di Indonesia : Tinjauan Model Teoritis Dan Aplikasi Pendahuluan.
Fitriani, A., Wahyuningsih, D. S., Muzakky, L., Suparni, Y., & City, T. (2025). The Role Of Zakat In Reducing Poverty And Improving. 6(2), 35–42.
Flores, J., Santos, L., & Tariq, U. (2025). Shariah Law and Economic Justice : Analyzing the Impact of Zakat on Income Distribution in Indonesia. 3(1), 104–115.
Fradana, A. N. (2025). CJPE : Cokroaminoto Juornal of Primary Education Efektivitas Literasi Digital untuk Pembelajaran di Sekolah Dasar Pendahuluan Kemampuan literasi dasar sangat diperlukan di era globalisasi karena. 8, 938–954.
Ginan. (2020). JURNAL. 04(03), 94–106.
Gisatriadi, N. (2024). Perkembangan Perbankan Syariah Di Era Digital. 3(2), 216–231.
Hafiz, A. P., Latif, M., Muhammad, P., & Umar, M. H. (2025). Analysis of the Indonesian Banking System : A Comparison Between Conventional and Sharia Banks. 8(2), 278–292. https://doi.org/10.58824/mediasas.v8i2.300
Hajar, A. (2024). Islamic Banking and Economic Development : Insights from Southeast Asia and the Middle East. 3, 162–175.
Hakim, A. (2024). Journal of Islamic Economics, Finance, and Banking | 1. 1–24.
Haridah. (2025). Jurnal Investasi Islam Jurnal Investasi Islam. 06, 818–828.
I Nopita Dw. (2023). Perbandingan Performa Keuangan Bank Syariah Dan. 3(1), 35–44.
Irawan, F. (2022). Pengaruh Faktor Permodalan, Kualitas Aset Dan Likuiditas Terhadap Profitabilitas Bank Umum Syariah Feri. 8(2).
Jordy, M., & M, S. (2025). Analisis Implikasi Capital Scructure , Operating Efficient dan Non-Interest Income. 23(1), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.26623/slsi.v23i1.9600
Kharismawati, D., Banking, I., Syariah, P., Keuangan, K., & Kinerja, S. (2023). Strategi Peningkatan Kinerja Keuangan Perbankan Syariah Setelah Pandemi. 1(1), 22–28.
Kristianti, I., & Tulenan, M. V. (2021). Dampak financial technology terhadap kinerja keuangan perbankan. 18(1), 57–65.
Kurniawati, R. (2021). Analisis credit crunch bank umum konvensional dan bank umum syariah di indonesia. 27.
Lestari, L. B., & Afandi, A. (2020). Analisis Pengaruh Karakteristik Bank, Faktor Makroekonomi terhadap Pembiayaan Sektor UMKM pada Perbankan Syariah di Indonesia. Jurnal Baabu Al-Ilmi: Ekonomi Dan Perbankan Syariah, 5(2), 164. https://doi.org/10.29300/ba.v5i2.3532
Meero, A. (2025). Islamic vs . Conventional Banking in the Age of FinTech and AI : Evolving Business Models , Efficiency , and Stability ( 2020 – 2024 ).
Mokoagow, F. R. (2024). Kepatuhan Syariah dalam Aktivitas Bisnis Perbankan Syariah : Analisis Yuridis Normatif. 4(1), 44–53.
Mulyani, R. D. (2025). Analisis Kinerja Keuangan Ditinjau dari Aspek Likuiditas , Solvabilitas , dan Profitabilitas pada PT BCA TBK yang terdaftar di BEI Tahun 2021 – 2024. 2(1).
Na, F. (2021). Pengaruh Profil Risiko Dan Permodalan Terhadap Kinerja Keuangan Bank Syariah ( Studi Pada Bank Umum Syariah Yang. 1, 369–386.
Nasution, A. M. (2025). Digital Financial Transformation And. 4(2), 73–89.
Nasution, F. H. (2024). Materialisme dalam Tafsir Sayyid Qutb: Studi Atas Q.S Ali Imran Ayat 14. TAJDID: Jurnal Ilmu Ushuluddin, 23(2), 620–647. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.30631/tjd.v23i2.519
Noviani, T. A., & Sofiana, A. (2025). Zakat Fund Management through Financial Technology in the Digital Era : A Maqā ṣ id al- Sharī ‘ ah Approach. 25(2).
Nugraheni, P. (2024). A Framework To Improve The Implementation Of Business Ethics In Islamic Business Organisations. https://doi.org/10.1108/17538390911006340/full/html>.ibid.
Nuri Zh. (2017). Analisis profitabilitas perbankan syariah di indonesia sebagai dampak dari efisiensi operasional. 1(2), 194–209.
Nurjanah, D. I., Anisa, R., Darmawan, D., Mitra, P., & Jaweda, C. (2024). Konsep Gharar dan Maisir dalam Transaksi Ekonomi Fikih Mu ’ amalah. 2(3), 159–166. https://doi.org/10.59996/al-fiqh.v2i3.368
Pratomo, D. (2021). 1* , 2 1,2. Derivatif : Jurnal Manajemen, 15(2).
Puja, V. dan. (2023). Pengaruh Penggunaan Digitalisasi Zakat Terhadap Efektivitas Dalam Pengumpulan Zakat Pada Baznas Kalbar. 1(1), 43–53.
Purkon, A. (2013). A Hermeneutic Approach in the Study of Islamic Law. Ahkam: Jurnal Ilmu Syariah, 13(2), 183–192. https://doi.org/10.15408/ajis.v13i2.930
R. Pertiwi, YS, D. (2020). Faktor yang memengaruhi kredit bermasalah bank konvensional dan syariah di indonesia. 6(1), 118–127.
Rahmawati, P. A., & Nisa, F. L. (2024). Analisis Manajemen Risiko pada Bank Syariah Indonesia. 75–82.
Ramadhani, N. M., & Agustin, S. (2025). Digitalisasi Berbasis Syariah: Transformasi Teknologi Dalam Pengembangan Produk Dan Pembiayaan Bank Syariah Nurhania, Naila Maryam Ramadhani, Reni, Sisilia Agustin. 3(2), 232–243.
Rianda, C. N. (2024). Prinsip dan Konsep Dasar Bank. 1(2), 100–106.
Rika Widianita, D. (2023). By the blessings of almighty god governor of bank indonesia,. At-tawassuth: Jurnal Ekonomi Islam, VIII(I), 1–19.
Rosidi, A., Zainuddin, M., & Arifiana, I. (2024). Metode Dalam Penelitian Hukum Normatif Dan Sosiologis ( Field Research ). 2(1), 46–58.
S. Rahmani, K. (2025). Harmonisasi fatwa dan regulasi perbankan syariah. 6(02), 133–144.
Sunarsih, S. (2017). Analisis Perbandingan Tingkat Efisiensi Perbankan Syari ’ ah dan Konvensional di Indonesia Sunarsih Pendahuluan Sejak 1 Mei 1992 Bank Muamalah Indonesia ( BMI ) mulai beroperasi dan memberikan pelayanan perbankan secara Islam kepada para nasabahnya . Perb. 51(1).
Syarbaini, A. M. B. (2025). Distributing Zakatu Kasbil ’ Amal as an Alternative to Student Funding , Evidence in Indonesia ’ s Universities. 1–25.
Trimulyana, R. A. (2024). Transformasi Digital dalam Perbankan Syariah dan Dampaknya pada Masyarakat Muslim. 2, 8–12.
Umum, B., & Di, K. (2018). Keuangan bank umum syariah vs indonesia dengan menggunakan. 3(1).
Vanessa Leony, R. P. (2022). No Title. 4320(2), 223–244.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Ahmad Baidawi Ramadani, Sami Ayu Lestari
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
